Saturday, February 6, 2010

Don't Glamorize 'Avatar'-A Parallel Story from the Real World - Ancient Tribe Becomes Extinct as Last Member Dies




David Knowles, Writer

Feb. 5) – Marking the end of a language and an entire people, the last member of the Bo, an ancient tribe that lived in the Andaman Islands, has died.



When Boa Sr, as she was known, died last week, she was believed to be about 85 years old. Her husband had died years beforehand, and Boa, whose name means "land" or "earth" in the Bo language, had no children.



The Bo are believed to have first come to the Andaman Islands – located roughly 850 miles off India's east coast in the Bay of Bengal – 65,000 years ago. Bo was one of at least 10 pre-colonial languages spoken on the islands.



According to Survival International, an advocacy group for native peoples throughout the world, the Bo were one of the oldest surviving human cultures on earth.



Of the thousands of Great Andamanese who once inhabited the islands, only 52 people are still alive today. But Boa Sr, who also spoke a local dialect of Hindi as well as the amalgam language called Great Andamanese, was the last of her particular tribe."



After the death of her parents, Boa was the last Bo speaker for 30 to 40 years," Abbi told the BBC.



The video footage above, courtesy of CNN, was recorded over the last few years of Boa's life by Abbi and represents the some of the last recorded utterances and song in Bo.



The Bos' Downfall



In 1858, when the British decided to colonize the Andaman Islands and use them as a penal colony, they estimated that 5,000 Great Andamanese lived there. "



At first, the British didn't notice any difference between the tribes," said Sophie Grig, senior campaigner at Survival International.



But in 1879, a British officer named M.V. Portman was appointed officer in charge of the Andamanese, and after years of attempting to acclimate them to life as British subjects, Portman wrote "A Manual of the Andamanese Languages," which distinguished the differences among tribal languages.



Portman's own obituary, which appeared in The Times on Feb. 22, 1935, reads:



In many parts of the islands the natives were still either ferocious enemies



or at best half-tamed; and his work consisted in making contact with them



and very gradually bringing them to recognize the value of British rule.





But colonization proved ruinous for the tribes of the Andamans, including the Bo, with large numbers decimated by measles and syphilis brought to the islands by foreigners. Many of those who were left gravitated to alcohol, another import to the islands, as a way of seeking solace.



"When people are dispossessed from their land and their way of life, they often turn to alcohol," Grig said. "It's not surprising, and it was very much true in the case of the Bo."



In 1970 the Indian government began relocating the Bo to a settlement of concrete row houses on Strait Island. Boa Sr was moved in 1978, and Abbi said she often said that she missed her old life in the jungle. "



What's important is that we learn from this lesson and do everything we can to protect the remaining tribes like the Jarawa and the Sentinelese, who are still there and remain threatened," Grig said.



Now kept in a protective quarantine by the Indian government, the Sentinelese received worldwide attention in 2004, when they were filmed running out of the jungle firing arrows at passing helicopters shortly after the Asian tsunami killed thousands on the Andaman and Nicobar island chains.



Abbi argues that preventing the extinction of other Andamanese languages is crucial if we hope to expand our understanding of how language in the region evolved over time.



"It is generally believed that all Andamanese languages might be the last representatives of those languages which go back to pre-Neolithic times," Abbi told the BBC.



But the death of a language also has other implications. "



A language contains the memories and experiences, everything that explains and encapsulates a way of life," Grig said. "It's sad for the entire world."





This story is so important, that we're presenting two articles covering the passing of Boa Sr. Each article offers a slightly different perspective, allowing you to grasp this great loss more fully.

Kentke


By Harmeet Shah Singh, CNN


February 5, 2010 10:14 a.m. EST



New Delhi, India (CNN) -- The last member of an ancient tribe that has inhabited an Indian island chain for around 65,000 years has died, a group that campaigns for the protection of indigenous peoples has said.


Boa Sr, who was around 85 years of age, died last week in the Andaman islands, about 750 miles off India's eastern coast, Survival International said in a statement.


The London-based group, which works to protect indigenous peoples, said she was the last member of one of ten distinct Great Andamanese tribes, the Bo.


"The Bo are thought to have lived in the Andaman islands for as long as 65,000 years, making them the descendants of one of the oldest human cultures on earth," it noted.


With her passing at a hospital, India also lost one of its most endangered languages, also called Bo, linguists say.



"She was the last speaker of (the) Bo language. It pains to see how one by one we are losing speakers of Great Andamanese and (their) language is getting extinct. (It is) A very fast erosion of (the) indigenous knowledge base, that we all are helplessly witnessing," read an obituary in Boa Sr's honor posted on the Web site of the Vanishing Voices of the Great Andamanese (VOGA) project.



Project director Anvita Abbi, a professor at New Delhi's Jawaharlal Nehru University, met with Boa as recently as last year. "She was the only member who remembered the old songs," Abbi recounted in her obituary.



"Boa Sr was the only speaker of Bo and had no one to converse with in that language," Abbi told CNN. Her husband and children had already died, the linguist said.



Other than Bo, she also knew local Andaman languages, which she would use to converse, according to Abbi.



Boa Sr was believed to be the oldest of the Great Andamanese, members of ten distinct tribes. Survival International estimates there are now just 52 Great Andamanese left.



There were believed to be 5,000 of them when the British colonized the archipelago in 1858. Most of those tribal communities were subsequently killed or died of diseases, says Survival International.



The British also held the indigenous tribes people captive in what was called an Andaman Home, but none of the 150 children born there survived beyond two years of age, according to the group.



Boa Sr also survived the killer Indian Ocean tsunami in 2004.



She recorded in Bo what she saw when the giant waves arrived. "While we were all asleep, the water rose and filled all around. We did not get up before the water rose. Water filled where we were and as the morning broke the water started to recede," reads a translation of her tsunami narrative posted on the VOGA Web site.



Activists are expressing alarm over her death.



"Boa's loss is a bleak reminder that we must not allow this to happen to the other tribes of the Andaman islands," Survival director Stephen Corry said in the statement. Andaman and Nicobar Islands authorities put at least five tribes in their list of vulnerable indigenous communities.
According to Corry's group, the surviving Great Andamanese depend largely on the Indian government for food and shelter and abuse of alcohol is rife.



Among the tribes are the Sentinelese, who inhabit a 60-square-kilometer island.



Officials believe the group is probably the world's only surviving Paleolithic people without contact with any other community. They said the Sentinelese are very hostile and never leave their Island. Very little is known about them.


11 comments:

  1. Powerful. Thank you for post.

    ReplyDelete
  2. girl, isn't this powerful.

    thank you for posting the other article it really helped me round out and sink deep into the significance of this...peace. gale

    ReplyDelete
  3. Did I thank you for making me aware of the story? I posted it yesterday.

    It's so timely, with all the public fascination with 'Avatar'.

    Interesting to me too Gale, is how I can see correlations with the current downfall of the economic system.

    The demise of Boa Sr's world and culture is the other side of the coin in the stockholder's pocket.

    Stockholders? What do stockholders have to do with this?

    It is responding to the mandate of the stockholders that initiates the violence that destroys the harmony of balanced pristine worlds, such as Cameron tried to create as the Na'Vi world on Pandora.

    And what is that mandate? Bring me back profit and wealth for my investment. By any means necessary, and at any cost.

    Here's the wikipedia page on the Andaman Islands. It's well worth the read. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andaman_islands


    Boa Sr's death is the last item noted under 'Recent History'.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi again Kentke, such a wise lady,


    I found the new posts on your blog interesting - I had previously read briefly about a language having gone extinct with the passing of the last member of its tribe - and the info in your blog helped amplify that a lot.

    But the video about Boa Sr at top of the blog entry was interesting too, listening to her song about the Tsunami.

    Then I suddenly felt a great grief, took awhile to pass, quite a surprise. From where it came I don't know. Seemed to come from way, way back. Interesting.

    When the grief had settled mostly, it was a quiet message to do what i can to help or the whole human race will go the same way.

    And thanks again for that CNN video in your blog about Boa Sr. You continue to have a very well made and interesting blog!


    Jim

    ReplyDelete
  5. Jim~
    Your appreciation of seeing the video makes all the difficulty I go thru to get it up there worth it!

    Wasn't she a beautiful woman? What a great smile. And you know, her name, "Boa", is the feminine form of the Portuguese word for 'good'.

    Always appreciate your comments.

    ReplyDelete
  6. we're living in the bosom of a madman.
    a mad scientist who desperately needs
    to control all and won't stop at nothing
    until it comes to pass...


    thing is he never understood he was not
    the supreme godhead...


    i'm with chief joseph, crazy horse and
    all my ancestors attempting to sit still
    and let what needs to pass come to
    pass.

    ReplyDelete
  7. So sad there where no defector of western privilege like in the fantasy film Avitar to rescue these indigenous people from the deadly clutches of genocide and colonialism. Unfortunately the type of consciousness that give rise to this type of cold brutishness is pandemic at this time in history and has spread across the earth live a horrible disease. The murder of innocence are old stories now, we know them very well my question is where are the soulutions? What are we to do to counter this negativity and evil. I know how it looks and operates I've been knowing that for the past forty years what I don't know is what can we do about it that is sustainable healing and honoring to those who have perished in its wake and those that continue to suffer in its presence.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Excellent and moving post, Kentke - I'm glad you shared the story. I take issue with one of your commentators.

    Umm, GlobalHeart... I'm fairly certain that the Western 'protector' is exactly the problem here.

    Avatar glorifies a kind of backhanded respect, a desire to maintain the 'savage races' in an original state, as if they were more pure or innocent than us (i.e. to treat them like children or pets, rather than people). When discussing something like the final member of a unique culture passing away, I think it's a little out of line to suggest that a pedantic film - which exists only to put money in the hands of modern imperialists - will provide some kind of solution. If this is an honest response, then you are very much part of the problem, dear.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thank you Global Heart and Lilo for sharing your perceptions. I hope you won't mind my addressing both of you.

    We're definately reaching the full hearted intelligent people that are out there.

    That people of such deep thinking, sensitivity, and obvious life experience as yourselves, stop here to read and offer their thoughts, is so encouraging.

    The right questions, good suggestions, solutions and transforming information that can fill in what I like to call those 'holes in our souls', are within you.
    Please keep them coming.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I must come clean here though...

    My review of the film Avatar was so harsh and full of profanity, that I couldn't bring it to the blog.

    I try very hard here, to be balanced, and civil. I try to present Knewz in a way that all people can relate and get in on the discussion.

    I have not yet mastered the new language we will need, in order to speak of things frankly, and not be attacked as being racist or bigoted.

    And there was so much of the antiquated way of thinking and seeing people and resources in that film, that I just slid back into old ways of describing it.

    There's a contingent within the viewing public and within the Black community that sees that film as an expression of a White supremist colonizing mind.

    I shared in my review, that I still have that image of James Cameron screaming, "I'm the king of the world!" after 'Titanic' winning it all at the Academy Awards years ago. Now having seen Avatar, these many years later, his declaration echos as a powerfully telling statement about his psyche.

    Anyway....I'm chalking Avatar up with the glut of TV reality shows that fill the airwaves, as just more evidence that Hollywood cinema is devoid of real creative genius.

    Technological tricks that machines effect, they have. But real drama ~ stories that are fresh,or humor that is not demeaning and hurtful, no. Television thanks to cable has been more interesting.

    The realm of entertainment and the media are the same as the state of politics and government. If people do not demand more or better, or make their displeasure felt, it seems we will end up with an experience that has a lot of flash and glamour, but at it's core is mediocre at best.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Lilo, I won't belabor this dialog perhaps I need to communicate with more clarity but I was actually being cynical not truly expecting the white guy to really rescue anybody. I am truly sorry that you misread what I said. Peace

    ReplyDelete

Labels

Absence of citizen online privacy protection by U S government (1) achievements of women (1) Africa human rights (1) africa political violence (1) African Muslims want peace (1) African politics (1) African refugee assisting homeland (1) African violence and corruption (1) African-American art (1) agriculture biotechnology industry (1) alQaida in Africa (1) American economic system (1) American education (1) American labor movement (2) American prison system (1) American racism (1) animals (1) Animals and humans (3) anti-American Middle Eastern cyber hijackers (1) apartheid 20 years gone (1) Arnold (1) Art by artists of African descent both continental (1) Atlanta (1) Avatar (1) Barack Obama (2) BeeSweet Lemonade (1) beneficial presence in the world (1) Bill Clinton (1) biogenetics (1) birthday (1) Black male role models (1) Black men unjustly incarcerated (1) Black people worldwide (1) busting American myths (1) buyer beware (1) Caribbean Literature Book Club 2010 reading list (1) champions (1) change for america world (1) charity (1) charter schools (2) China (1) classy artists (1) Congo (1) Consumer Rights (1) consumerism (1) Cornel West (1) Cosmos (1) coups in Africa (1) creativity built from our culture (1) credit game (1) Crenshaw community (1) cyberspace brought into wars (1) Dark Matter (1) David Bowie (1) Dedan Gills (1) delusions of the American masse (1) democracy in the world (1) destroying myths that no longer serve the good (1) Dialogue in America (1) diaspora (1) Disgust; Being our true selves (1) distribution of wealth (1) donating (1) earthworms (1) ecologically smart cars; green lifestyle (1) ecology (1) economic meltdown (1) economics (1) Edge intellectuals (1) Education in America (1) Egypt (1) elevating consciousness of American people (1) endangered Mountain Gorillas (1) European internet privacy (1) Excellent athletes (1) expanding consciousness (1) fear and greed of white people (1) female corporate/ multinational CEOs (1) first blog of the year (1) freedom of the press (1) French and Mali troops roust al-Qaida Islamist invaders (1) G-20 (1) gardeners (1) giving (1) global immigration issues; Israel (1) golf (1) Good works in Africa by her children in the diaspora (1) gospel music (1) Gratitude (1) Groups doing great work (1) Haitian Earthquake relief effort (2) helping others globally (1) History of issue of race in America (1) Homophobia (1) Human omniaction (1) ignorance (1) imperialism (1) indigenious people (1) influencing purchasing trends with priming (1) Iraqi drones compromised (1) Islam (1) Islamic extremests in African; Timbuktu (2) jokes (1) Kenya bloggers (1) latest scientific discoveries (1) law (1) Los Angeles life; architecture; African-Americans in Los Angeles (2) lost world cultures (1) Love (1) Malcolm X Civil Rights Leader (1) Mali (3) Mali 2013 (1) manipulating the food of the world (1) manuscripts of Africa's past (1) men of integrity (1) men standing strong (1) Mikhail Khodorkovsky (1) military power in Afrcia (1) military power in Africa (1) Monsanto (1) MTV (1) Mugabe (2) my travels (1) Natalie Cole (1) National Parks (1) Native Americans (1) Nature at It's Best File (3) Nelson Mandela (1) Neuromelanin (1) New Yorker Magazine (1) Nigerian terrorist (1) Nobel Peace Prize winners (1) Obama as a balm (1) Obama diplomacy (1) Obama foreign diplomacy (1) Obama in Europe (1) Obama nobel prize winner (1) Obama policies regarding average citizens (1) Obama's ability to control and steer his administration (1) Octavvia E. Butler (1) order (1) organic (1) outstanding Black authors (1) Pan-African authors (1) personal fulfillment (1) Pharonic sacred science (1) photography - wildlife (1) Plant sentience (1) policies that endanger animal welfare (2) politics (1) positive life lessons (1) post-neocolonialism in Africa (1) poverty field studies in India (1) prejudice (1) priming (1) professionals (1) public protest of economic policies (1) race (1) race and housing (2) race in America (1) Racism in Hollywood (1) religious bigotry (1) right wing christians (1) right-wing fundamentalism (1) Russia (1) Russian politics (1) Sarah Palin's politics (1) Science - intelligent creative bacteria (1) scientific ignorance perpetuated in 2012 (1) sibling rivalry (1) Snoop Dogg (2) soil science (1) Somalia (1) South Africa labor problems (1) South side Chicago (1) Spring poetry (1) Stanford University (1) successful women (1) Sudan (2) technology (1) tennis (2) Thanksgiving Day (1) The Bigs/multinational corporations (1) the failure of No Child Left Behind (1) the wealthy (1) things that make you go 'hhmmm' (1) Tiger Woods (1) Timbuktu libraries (1) time (1) Toni Morrison (1) true meaning of dogsledding. (1) Tuskegee Airmen (1) Twitter hijacked (1) U S History (1) vegan (1) vegetarianism (1) Virunga Park (1) ways to help Africa (1) weak results re: campaign promises (1) wealth in America (1) wholesome food sources (2) wildlife and their habitats (1) Williams sisters (2) Wimbledon (1) wolves (1) women leaders (1) world economy (1) writing (1) Xmas 2009 (1) yahoo (1) young Black entrepreneurs (1) Zimbabwe election (1)