Like most children, Margaret Howe Lovatt grew up with stories of
talking animals. "There was this book that my mother gave to me called
Miss Kelly,"
she remembers with a twinkle in her eye. "It was a story about a cat
who could talk and understand humans and it just stuck with me that
maybe there is this possibility."
Unlike most children, Lovatt
didn't leave these tales of talking animals behind her as she grew up.
In her early 20s, living on the Caribbean island of St Thomas, they took
on a new significance. During Christmas 1963, her brother-in-law
mentioned a secret laboratory at the eastern end of the island where
they were working with
dolphins.
She decided to pay the lab a visit early the following year. "I was
curious," Lovatt recalls. "I drove out there, down a muddy hill, and at
the bottom was a cliff with a big white building."
Lovatt was met by a tall man with tousled hair, wearing an open shirt and smoking a cigarette. His name was
Gregory Bateson, a great intellectual of the 20th century and the director of the lab. "Why did you come here?" he asked Lovatt.
"Well,
I heard you had dolphins," she replied, "and I thought I'd come and see
if there was anything I could do or any way I could help…" Unused to
unannounced visitors and impressed by her bravado, Bateson invited her
to meet the animals and asked her to watch them for a while and write
down what she saw. Despite her lack of scientific training, Lovatt
turned out to be an intuitive observer of animal behaviour and Bateson
told her she could come back whenever she wanted.
"There were
three dolphins," remembers Lovatt. "Peter, Pamela and Sissy. Sissy was
the biggest. Pushy, loud, she sort of ran the show. Pamela was very shy
and fearful. And Peter was a young guy. He was sexually coming of age
and a bit naughty."
The lab's upper floors overhung a sea pool
that housed the animals. It was cleaned by the tide through openings at
each end. The facility had been designed to bring humans and dolphins
into closer proximity and was the brainchild of an American
neuroscientist,
Dr John Lilly. Here, Lilly hoped to commune with the creatures, nurturing their ability to make human-like sounds through their blow holes.
Lilly had been interested in connecting with
cetaceans
since coming face to face with a beached pilot whale on the coast near
his home in Massachusetts in 1949. The young medic couldn't quite
believe the size of the animal's brain – and began to imagine just how
intelligent the creature must have been, explains Graham Burnett,
professor of the history of science at Princeton and author of
The Sounding of the Whale.
"You are talking about a time in science when everybody's thinking
about a correlation between brain size and what the brain can do. And in
this period, researchers were like: 'Whoa… big brain huh… cool!'"
Tripper and flipper: Dr John Lilly, who started experimenting with LSD during the project. Photograph: Lilly Estate
At every opportunity in the years that followed, John Lilly and his
first wife, Mary, would charter sailboats and cruise the Caribbean,
looking for other big-brained marine mammals to observe. It was on just
such a trip in the late 1950s that the Lillys came across Marine Studios
in Miami – the first place to keep the bottlenose dolphin in
captivity.
Up until this time, fishermen on America's east coast,
who were in direct competition with dolphins for fish, had considered
the animals vermin. "They were know as 'herring hogs' in most of the
seafaring towns in the US," says Burnett. But here, in the tanks of
Marine Studios, the dolphins' playful nature was endearingly on show and
their ability to learn tricks quickly made it hard to dislike them.
Here,
for the first time, Lilly had the chance to study the brains of live
dolphins, mapping their cerebral cortex using fine probes, which he'd
first developed for his work on the brains of
rhesus monkeys.
Unable to sedate dolphins, as they stop breathing under anaesthetic,
the brain-mapping work wasn't easy for either animals or scientists, and
the research didn't always end well for the marine mammals. But on one
occasion in 1957, the research would take a different course which would
change his and Mary's lives for ever.
Now aged 97, Mary still
remembers the day very clearly. "I came in at the top of the operating
theatre and heard John talking and the dolphin would go: 'Wuh… wuh…
wuh' like John, and then Alice, his assistant, would reply in a high
tone of voice and the dolphin would imitate her voice. I went down to
where they were operating and told them that this was going on and they
were quite startled."
Perhaps, John reasoned, this behaviour
indicated an ambition on the dolphins' part to communicate with the
humans around them. If so, here were exciting new opportunities for
interspecies communication. Lilly published his theory in a book in 1961
called
Man and Dolphin. The idea of talking dolphins, eager to tell us something, captured the public's imagination and the book became a bestseller.
Man and Dolphin
extrapolated Mary Lilly's initial observations of dolphins mimicking
human voices, right through to teaching them to speak English and on
ultimately to a Cetacean Chair at the United Nations, where all marine
mammals would have an enlightening input into world affairs, widening
our perspectives on everything from science to history, economics and
current affairs.
Lilly's theory had special significance for
another group of scientists – astronomers. "I'd read his book and was
very impressed," says Frank Drake, who had just completed the first
experiment to detect signals from extraterrestrial civilisations using a
radio telescope at Green Bank in West Virginia. "It was a very exciting
book because it had these new ideas about creatures as intelligent and
sophisticated as us and yet living in a far different milieu." He
immediately saw parallels with Lilly's work, "because we [both] wanted
to understand as much as we could about the challenges of communicating
with other intelligent species." This interest helped Lilly win
financial backing from Nasa and other government agencies, and Lilly
opened his new lab in the Caribbean in 1963, with the aim of nurturing
closer relationships between man and dolphin.
A few months LATER,
in early 1964, Lovatt arrived. Through her naturally empathetic nature
she quickly connected with the three animals and, eager to embrace John
Lilly's vision for building an interspecies communication bridge, she
threw herself into his work, spending as much time as possible with the
dolphins and carrying out a programme of daily lessons to encourage them
to make human-like sounds. While the lab's director, Gregory Bateson,
concentrated on animal-to-animal communication, Lovatt was left alone to
pursue Lilly's dream to teach the dolphins to speak English. But even
at a state-of-the-art facility like the Dolphin House, barriers
remained. "Every night we would all get in our cars and pull the garage
door down and drive away," remembers Lovatt. "And I thought: 'Well
there's this big brain floating around all night.' It amazed me that
everybody kept leaving and I just thought it was wrong."
Lovatt
reasoned that if she could live with a dolphin around the clock,
nurturing its interest in making human-like sounds, like a mother
teaching a child to speak, they'd have more success. "Maybe it was
because I was living so close to the lab. It just seemed so simple. Why
let the water get in the way?" she says. "So I said to John Lilly: 'I
want to plaster everything and fill this place with water. I want to
live here.'"
The radical nature of Lovatt's idea appealed to Lilly
and he went for it. She began completely waterproofing the upper floors
of the lab, so that she could actually flood the indoor rooms and an
outdoor balcony with a couple of feet of water. This would allow a
dolphin to live comfortably in the building with her for three months.
Lovatt
selected the young male dolphin called Peter for her live-in
experiment. "I chose to work with Peter because he had not had any
human-like sound training and the other two had," she explains. Lovatt
would attempt to live in isolation with him six days a week, sleeping on
a makeshift bed on the elevator platform in the middle of the room and
doing her paperwork on a desk suspended from the ceiling and hanging
over the water. On the seventh day Peter would return to the sea pool
downstairs to spend time with the two female dolphins at the lab –
Pamela and Sissy.
'If I was sitting with my legs in the water, he'd come up and look
at the back of my knee for a long time': Margaret with Peter.
Photograph: courtesy Lilly Estate
By the summer of 1965, Lovatt's domestic dolphinarium was ready for
use. Lying in bed, surrounded by water that first night and listening
to the pumps gurgling away, she remembers questioning what she was
doing. "Human people were out there having dinner or whatever and here I
am. There's moonlight reflecting on the water, this fin and this bright
eye looking at you and I thought: 'Wow, why am I here?' But then you
get back into it and it never occurred to me not to do it. What I was
doing there was trying to find out what Peter was doing there and what
we could do together. That was the whole point and nobody had done
that."
Audio recordings of Lovatt's progress, meticulously
archived on quarter-inch tapes at the time, capture the energy that
Lovatt brought to the experiment – doggedly documenting Peter's progress
with her twice-daily lessons and repeatedly encouraging him to greet
her with the phrase 'Hello Margaret'. "'M' was very difficult," she
remembers. "My name. Hello 'M'argaret. I worked on the 'M' sound and he
eventually rolled over to bubble it through the water. That 'M', he
worked on so hard."
For Lovatt, though, it often wasn't these
formal speech lessons that were the most productive. It was just being
together which taught her the most about what made Peter tick. "When we
had nothing to do was when we did the most," she reflects. "He was very,
very interested in my anatomy. If I was sitting here and my legs were
in the water, he would come up and look at the back of my knee for a
long time. He wanted to know how that thing worked and I was so charmed
by it."
Carl Sagan, one of the young astronomers at Green Bank,
paid a visit to report back on progress to Frank Drake. "We thought that
it was important to have the dolphins teach us 'Dolphinese', if there
is such a thing," recalls Drake. "For example we suggested two dolphins
in each tank not able to see each other – and he should teach one
dolphin a procedure to obtain food – and then see if it could tell the
other dolphin how to do the same thing in its tank. That was really the
prime experiment to be done, but Lilly never seemed able to do it."
Instead,
he encouraged Lovatt to press on with teaching Peter English. But there
was something getting in the way of the lessons. "Dolphins get sexual
urges," says the vet Andy Williamson, who looked after the animals'
health at Dolphin House. "I'm sure Peter had plenty of thoughts along
those lines."
"Peter liked to be with me," explains Lovatt. "He
would rub himself on my knee, or my foot, or my hand. And at first I
would put him downstairs with the girls," she says. But transporting
Peter downstairs proved so disruptive to the lessons that, faced with
his frequent arousals, it just seemed easier for Lovatt to relieve his
urges herself manually.
"I allowed that," she says. "I wasn't
uncomfortable with it, as long as it wasn't rough. It would just become
part of what was going on, like an itch – just get rid of it, scratch it
and move on. And that's how it seemed to work out. It wasn't private.
People could observe it."
For Lovatt it was a precious thing,
which was always carried out with great respect. "Peter was right there
and he knew that I was right there," she continues. "It wasn't sexual on
my part. Sensuous perhaps. It seemed to me that it made the bond
closer. Not because of the sexual activity, but because of the lack of
having to keep breaking. And that's really all it was. I was there to
get to know Peter. That was part of Peter."
Innocent as they were,
Lovatt's sexual encounters with Peter would ultimately overshadow the
whole experiment when a story about them appeared in
Hustler magazine in the late 1970s. "I'd never even heard of
Hustler,"
says Lovatt. "I think there were two magazine stores on the island at
the time. And I went to one and looked and I found this story with my
name and Peter, and a drawing."
Sexploitation: Hustler magazine's take on the story in the late 1970s. Photograph: Lilly Estate
Lovatt bought up all the copies she could find, but the story was out
there and continues to circulate to this day on the web. "It's a bit
uncomfortable," she acknowledges. "The worst experiment in the world,
I've read somewhere, was me and Peter. That's fine, I don't mind. But
that was not the point of it, nor the result of it. So I just ignore
it."
Something else began to interrupt the study. Lilly had been
researching the mind-altering powers of the drug LSD since the early
1960s. The wife of Ivan Tors, the producer of the dolphin movie
Flipper,
had first introduced him to it at a party in Hollywood. "John and Ivan
Tors were really good friends," says Ric O'Barry of the Dolphin Project
(an organisation that aims to stop dolphin slaughter and exploitation
around the world) and a friend of Lilly's at the time. "Ivan was
financing some of the work on St Thomas. I saw John go from a scientist
with a white coat to a full blown hippy," he remembers.
For the
actor Jeff Bridges, who was introduced to Lilly by his father Lloyd,
Lilly's self-experimentation with LSD was just part of who he was. "John
Lilly was above all an explorer of the brain and the mind, and all
those drugs that expand our consciousness," reflects Bridges. "There
weren't too many people with his expertise and his scientific background
doing that kind of work."
In the 1960s a small selection of
neuroscientists like John Lilly were licensed to research LSD by the
American government, convinced that the drug had medicinal qualities
that could be used to treat mental-health patients. As part of this
research, the drug was sometimes injected into animals and Lilly had
been using it on his dolphins since 1964, curious about the effect it
would have on them.
Margaret Lovatt today. Photograph: Matt Pinner/BBC
Much to Lilly's annoyance, nothing happened. Despite his various
attempts to get the dolphins to respond to the drug, it didn't seem to
have any effect on them, remembers Lovatt. "Different species react to
different pharmaceuticals in different ways," explains the vet, Andy
Williamson. "A tranquilliser made for horses might induce a state of
excitement in a dog. Playing with pharmaceuticals is a tricky business
to say the least."
Injecting the dolphins with LSD was not
something Lovatt was in favour of and she insisted that the drug was not
given to Peter, which Lilly agreed to. But it was his lab, and they
were his animals, she recalls. And as a young woman in her 20s she felt
powerless to stop him giving LSD to the other two dolphins.
While
Lilly's experimentation with the drug continued, Lovatt persevered with
Peter's vocalisation lessons and grew steadily closer to him. "That
relationship of having to be together sort of turned into really
enjoying being together, and wanting to be together, and missing him
when he wasn't there," she reflects. "I did have a very close encounter
with – I can't even say a dolphin again – with Peter."
By autumn
1966, Lilly's interest in the speaking-dolphin experiment was dwindling.
"It didn't have the zing to it that LSD did at that time," recalls
Lovatt of Lilly's attitude towards her progress with Peter. "And in the
end the zing won."
The dolphinarium on St Thomas. Photograph: Lilly Estate
Lilly's cavalier attitude to the dolphins' welfare would eventually
be his downfall, driving away the lab's director, Gregory Bateson, and
eventually causing the funding to be cut. Just as Lovatt and Peter's
six-month live-in experiment was concluding, it was announced that the
lab would be closed.
Without funding, the fate of the dolphins was
in question. "I couldn't keep Peter," says Lovatt, wistfully. "If he'd
been a cat or a dog, then maybe. But not a dolphin." Lovatt's new job
soon became the decommissioning of the lab and she prepared to ship the
dolphins away to Lilly's other lab, in a disused bank building in Miami.
It was a far cry from the relative freedom and comfortable surroundings
of Dolphin House.
At the Miami lab, held captive in smaller tanks
with little or no sunlight, Peter quickly deteriorated, and after a few
weeks Lovatt received news.
"I got that phone call from John Lilly," she recalls. "John called me himself to tell me. He said Peter had committed suicide."
Ric
O'Barry corroborates the use of this word. "Dolphins are not automatic
air-breathers like we are," he explains. "Every breath is a conscious
effort. If life becomes too unbearable, the dolphins just take a breath
and they sink to the bottom. They don't take the next breath." Andy
Williamson puts Peter's death down to a broken heart, brought on by a
separation from Lovatt that he didn't understand. "Margaret could
rationalise it, but when she left, could Peter? Here's the love of his
life gone."
"I wasn't terribly unhappy about it," explains Lovatt,
50 years on. "I was more unhappy about him being in those conditions
[at the Miami lab] than not being at all. Nobody was going to bother
Peter, he wasn't going to hurt, he wasn't going to be unhappy, he was
just gone. And that was OK. Odd, but that's how it was."
In the
decades which followed, John Lilly continued to study dolphin-human
communications, exploring other ways of trying to talk to them – some of
it bizarrely mystical, employing telepathy, and some of it more
scientific, using musical tones. No one else ever tried to teach
dolphins to speak English again.
Instead, research has shifted to better understanding other species' own languages. At the
Seti (Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) Institute,
founded by Frank Drake to continue his work on life beyond Earth,
Drake's colleague Laurance Doyle has attempted to quantify the
complexity of animal language here on our home planet.
"There is
still this prejudice that humans have a language which is far and away
above any other species' qualitatively," says Doyle. "But by looking at
the complexity of the relationship of dolphin signals to each other,
we've discovered that they definitely have a very high communication
intelligence. I think Lilly's big insight was how intelligent dolphins
really are."
Margaret Howe Lovatt stayed on the island, marrying
the photographer who'd captured pictures of the experiment. Together
they moved back into Dolphin House, eventually converting it into a
family home where they brought up three daughters. "It was a good
place," she remembers. "There was good feeling in that building all the
time."
In the years that followed the house has fallen into
disrepair, but the ambition of what went on there is still remembered.
"Over the years I have received letters from people who are working with
dolphins themselves," she recalls. "They often say things like: 'When
I was seven I read about you living with a dolphin, and that's what
started it all for me.'"
Peter is their "Miss Kelly", she
explains, remembering her own childhood book about talking animals.
"Miss Kelly inspired me. And in turn the idea of my living with a
dolphin inspired others. That's fun. I like that."
Christopher Riley is the producer and director of The Girl Who Talked to Dolphins,
which will premiere at the Sheffield International Documentary Festival on 11 June, and is on BBC4 on 17 June at 9pm